House Leadership Afflicted with Linguine Spine Syndrome?

User Rating:  / 3
PoorBest 

The following article explains that the Republican-controlled House of Representatives has the unilateral authority to stop ObamaCare today, even with President Obama in office!  The only thing standing in the way of a defunding of ObamaCare is a lack of political will on the part of House Leadership.

Don't Blame Obama

by Walter E. Williams, Ph.D
published on 9/11/12

This example demonstrates that Congress has ultimate spending power and that when it suits favored interest groups, it will use it. Most members of our Republican-controlled House of Representatives say they’re against Obamacare. If they really were, they surely would attach a legislative rider or some other legislative device to the Department of Health and Human Services’ appropriation bill to ban spending any money on Obamacare; they have the power to. But they don’t have the political courage to do so, and their lives are made easier by the pretense that it’s the president controlling the spending. And we fall for it.

Let’s look at a minor case that demonstrates Congress’ appropriation powers. The California Navel Orange Commission is a government-sanctioned grower collusion that establishes production quotas so as to restrict supply in order to keep orange prices high. In 1980, the Federal Trade Commission was going to study such agriculture collusions, euphemistically called marketing orders, as a result of increasing criticism from economists, reformers in federal agencies, consumer groups and some orange growers. Big growers descended on Congress to protest the threat to their collusive behavior an FTC study might create. Congress, as a part of its FTC appropriation, prohibited the agency from monitoring marketing orders. In November 1983, Congress started using a legislative rider to prohibit the Office of Management and Budget from spending any money to review marketing orders.

Knowing which branch of government has the ultimate taxing and spending authority is vital. No matter how Obama’s presidency is viewed, if we buy into the notion that it’s he whose spending binge is crippling our nation through massive debt and deficits, we will naturally focus our attention on the White House. The fact of the matter is that Washington has been on a spending binge no matter who has occupied the White House. In 1970, federal spending was $926 billion. Today it’s $3.8 trillion. In inflation-adjusted dollars, that’s about a 300 percent increase. Believing that presidents have taxing and spending powers leaves Congress less politically accountable for our deepening economic quagmire. Of course, if you’re a congressman, not being held accountable is what you want.

Seeing as a president cannot spend one dime Congress does not first appropriate, what meaning can we attach to statements such as “under Barack Obama, government spending has increased 21 percent” and “under Barack Obama, welfare spending has increased 54 percent”? You ask, “Williams, are you saying Obama is without fault?” Let’s look at it.

There is little intellectually challenging about the fact that the Constitution gave Congress ultimate taxing and spending authority. My question is this: How can academics, politicians, news media people and ordinary citizens continually make and get away with statements such as “Reagan’s budget deficits,” “Clinton’s budget surplus,” “Bush’s tax cuts” and “Obama’s spending binge”? I know that the nation’s law schools teach little about Framer intent, but I wonder whether they tell students that it’s the executive branch of government that holds taxing and spending authority. Maybe it’s simply incurable ignorance, willful deception, sloppy thinking or just plain stupidity. If there’s an explanation that I’ve missed, I’d surely like to hear it.

Within the past decade, I’ve written columns titled “Deception 101,” “Stubborn ignorance” and “Exploiting public ignorance,” all explaining which branch of the federal government has taxing and spending authority. So here it is again: The first clause of Article I, Section 7 of the U.S. Constitution, generally known as the “origination clause,” reads: “All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills.” Constitutionally and by precedent, the House of Representatives has the exclusive prerogative to originate bills to appropriate money, as well as to raise revenues. The president is constitutionally permitted to propose tax and spending measures or veto them. Congress has the authority to ignore the president’s proposals and override his vetoes.

Walter E. Williams, Ph.D., is the John M. Olin Distinguished Professor of Economics at George Mason University in Fairfax, Va. He holds a Doctor of Humane Letters from Virginia Union University and Grove City College, Doctor of Laws from Washington and Jefferson College and Doctor Honoris Causa en Ciencias Sociales from Universidad Francisco Marroquin, in Guatemala, where he is also Professor Honorario.  Additionally, Dr. Williams is an occasional guest host on the Rush Limbaugh show.

Click here to view the article as originally post on World Net Daily

Latest Events

Mon Nov 10 @ 7:00PM - 08:30PM
RetakeOurGov Monthly Meeting-New Date

Our Financial Supporters

John R.  Fenton, MI

Kevin N.  Pinckney, MI

Linda W.  Brighton, MI

Margo A.  Olivet, MI

Jeffrey L.  Troy, MI

James B.  Saginaw, MI

Margaret P.  Jackson, MI

Kathleen D.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Bob J.  Hartland, MI

Robert J.  Northville, MI

Sandra B.  Highland, MI

Betty G.  Brighton, MI

Bob F.  Macomb Township, MI

Tomas  K.  Grandville, MI

Bob H.  Fenton, MI

Kevin C.  Rochester Hills, MI

Lillian S.  Bridgeport, MI

Jan H.  Fenton, MI

Tracy L.  Brighton, MI

Jill V.  Highland, MI

Judith C.  Flint, MI

Larry P.  Plymouth, MI

James A.  Waterford, MI

Daniel W.  Kalamazoo, MI

Richard and Phyllis I.  Georgetown, TX

Shari D.  Frankenmuth, MI

Angus W.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Dan W.  Brighton, MI

Robin H.  West Bloomfield, MI

Alfred H.  Howell, MI

Dave B.  White Lake, MI

Mac L.  Hartland, MI

Randal C.  Milford, MI

Richard G.  Howell, MI

Roger C.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Donna N.  Hartland, MI

Joseph R.  Chelsea, MI

Lana T.  Brighton, MI

Dan A.  Howell, MI

John C.  Gregory, MI

Patrick C.  South Lyon, MI

Stephen R.  Chesterfield, MI

Edward F.  Plymouth, MI

Wendy H.  Gregory, MI

Peggy M.  White Lake, MI

Deborah M.  Howell, MI

George B.  Howell, MI

Shannon W.  Howell, MI

Jack P.  Commerce Twp, MI

Steve P.  Northville, MI

Susan O.  White Lake, MI

Dennis M.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Marsha S.  Fenton, MI

Mary Lou H.  Livonia, MI

James K.  Dearborn, MI

Ronald B.  Sterling Heights, MI

Darleen P.  Plymouth, MI

Lou F.  Novi, MI

Margie W.  Farmington Hills, MI

Ronald M.  Grosse Pointe Park, MI

Ben D.  Milford, MI

Dierck O.  Northville, MI

Anna J.  West Bloomfield, MI

Clinton D.  Howell, MI

Karen C.  Farmington Hills, MI

Laura M.  Hartland, MI

Charles R.  Ypsilanti, MI

Lelton N.  Highland, MI

Charles M.  Brighton, MI

Shelly M.  Pinckney, MI

Marlene L.  Hartland, MI

John M.  Essexville, MI

Sarah B.  Hartland, MI

Joe H.  Hamburg, MI

Doug K.  Fenton, MI

Jim H.  Hartland, MI

John W.  White Lake, MI

Matthew O.  West Bloomfield, MI

Daniel H.  Milford, MI

Joella T.  Highland, MI

Merle R.  Walled Lake, MI

Linda O.  Fenton, MI

Leonard L.  Whitmore Lake, MI

Scott P.  Wixom, MI

Wendy S.  Brighton, MI

Janice L.  Fenton, MI

Joseph L.  Wyandotte, MI

Glenda M.  Holly, MI

Cathy R.  Saranac, MI

Robert B.  Clarkston, MI

Kay S.  Dewitt, MI

Mike K.  Commerce Twp, MI

Rick M.  Grosse Pointe Farms, MI

Jim S.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Mark N.  Warren, MI

Marvin N.  Pinckney, MI

Brian F.  Webberville, MI

Matt B.  Farmington Hills , MI

Joyce K.  Westland, MI

Deborah P.  White Lake, MI

Marilyn O.  Commerce Township, MI

Laura Q.  Fenton, MI

James M.  Fenton, MI

Tanya K.  Fenton, MI

Tom S.  White Lake, MI

George W.  Whitmore Lake, MI

Gary and Kathleen K.  Ironwod, MI

Lill & Jim  M.  W. Bloomfield, MI

Don B.  Highland, MI

Brad S.  Rochester Hills, MI

Vickie K.  Farmington Hills, MI

W. Charles G.  Onsted, MI

Luigi M.  Hartland, MI

Charles K.  Highland, MI

Richard B.  Northville Twp, MI

James L.  Pinckney, MI

Gary K.  Redford, MI

Gary M.  Brighton, MI

Janice D.  Troy, MI

Jennifer D.  Howell, MI

Eric S.  Tampa, FL

Thomas C.  Rochester Hills, MI

Tim V.  Wayne, MI

Gloria H.  Troy, MI

John S.  Boyne City, MI

Stella .  Davisburg, MI

Terry G.  Saginaw, MI

Christine S.  Hartland, MI

Cynthia D.  Fowlerville, MI

Jason H.  Fenton, MI

Richard S.  Battle Creek, MI

Renee G.  Fenton, MI

Michael S.  Hell, MI

Donn W.  Farmington Hills, MI

John G.  Fowlerville, MI

Joseph F.  Lansing, MI

Roy V.  South Lyon, MI

Tom R.  Fairhaven, MI

Edmund K.  Northville, MI

Sue M.  Pinckney, MI

Marlene B.  Pinckney, MI

Russell G.  Brighton, MI

Craig O.  Holly, MI

B.H. A.  Troy, MI

Jeff M.  Howell, MI

Stacia L.  Waterford, MI

Jim M.  Pinckney, MI

Sandy W.  Lake Orion, MI

Joanne T.  Carleton, MI

David D.  Fenton, MI

Kim J.  Garden City, MI

Gregg C.  South Lyon, MI

Robert J.  Hartland, MI

Terry S.  Trenton, MI

Mary M.  Brighton, MI

Dave D.  Linden, MI

Fred D.  Fowlerville, MI

Cheryl W.  Washington, MI

Glenn N.  Howell, MI

James M.  Highland, MI

Gerri D.  Fenton, MI

Myron Z.  West Bloomfield, MI

Shawn M.  Pinckney, MI

Jim H.  Wixom, MI

Mark K.  Shelby Twp, MI

Donald T.  Dexter, MI

Geri C.  Royal Oak, MI

Bill H.  Mt. Clemens, MI

Daniel K.  West Bloomfield, MI

Norman S.  Williamston, MI

Roger K.  Saginaw, MI

Kevin S.  Farmington, MI

Larry V.  Whitmore Lake, MI

Douglas W.  Commerce Township, MI

Judy M.  Hell, MI

Dianna B.  Stockbridge, MI

Jenny C.  Brighton, MI

Joelle A.  Highland, MI

Joellen P.  Milford, MI

Rick W.  Grand Blanc, MI

T. L.  Livionia, MI

Jerry W.  Brighton, MI

Sharon L.  Plymouth, MI

Dianne C.  Bay City, MI

Joanie P.  Howell, MI

Sharon M.  Brighton, MI

Laura B.  Hartland, MI

Steven B.  Livonia, MI

Bobby N.  Colorado Springs, CO

Kathryn C.  Farmington Hills, MI

Mike P.  Dimondale, MI

David S.  Hartland, MI

Jeff S.  Lansing, MI

Maribeth S.  Plymouth, MI

Elsa E.  Pinckney, MI

Tom K.  Auburn Hills, MI

Diane H.  Fenton, MI

Ron W.  Plymouth, MI

Suzanne P.  Downers Grove, IL

Marilyn D.  Howell, MI

Amy S.  Howell, MI

Janie M.  Macomb Twp, MI

Ruth J.  Davisburg, MI

Robin B.  Linden, MI

Carol W.  Fenton, MI

Gregory H.  Howell, MI

John G.  Rochester, MI

Ralph T.  Plymouth, MI

Charles H.  Hartland, MI

Dave R.  Howell, MI

Jane H.  Howell, MI

Dick B.  Bloomfield, MI

James B.  Saginaw, MI

John B.  Fowlerville, MI

Ken M.  Pinckney, MI

Ray M.  Howell, MI

Judson E.  Milford, MI

Robert C.  Farmington Hills, MI

Nancy M.  Tampa, FL

Darlene L.  Charlotte, MI

Thelma G.  Berrien Springs, MI

John N.  Ann Arbor, MI

Christine C.  Howell, MI

Delores W.  Augusta, MI

Lynn R.  Fenton, MI

Donna R.  Burton , MI

Maria S.  Fenton, MI

Sarah L.  Commerce Twp, MI

GREG E.  PLYMOUTH, MI

Deborah O.  West Bloomfield, MI

Jon W.  Augusta, MI

Robert M.  Birmingham, MI

Arlene C.  Brighton, MI

Fadwa G.  Royal Oak, MI

Gail G.  Royal Oak, MI

A. Jean W.  Addison Twp, MI

Diana A.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Mark W.  Howell, MI

Ron S.  Fowlerville, MI

Dustin B.  Onsted, MI

Glenn H.  Lansing, MI

Harry H.  Novi, MI

JAMES E.  Bellaire, MI

Bob G.  Howell, MI

Mark P.  Howell, MI

Shelly S.  Wixom, MI

Christine S.  Hartland, MI

Dave R.  Grand Blanc, MI

Karen B.  Fenton, MI

Larry G.  Hartland, MI

Carol  V.  Lansing, MI

Joanne D.  Highland, MI

Patricia B.  Northville, MI

Gary and Jane G.  Grand Rapids, MI

Marcia D.  Fenton, MI

Rockie A.  Eastpointe, MI

Erick A.  Lake Orion, MI

Tony D.  Waterford, MI

Valerie K.  Farmington, MI

Jay T.  Clarkston, MI

Dustin G.  New Hudson, MI

Fred B.  Commerce Township, MI

William B.  Howell, MI

Kenneth B.  Howell, MI

Edward S.  Brighton, MI

Constance M.  Pinckney, MI

Conrad F.  Brighton, MI

Ronda H.  Brighton, MI

Robert M.  Coldwater, MI

Terry N.  Howell, MI

Rich F.  Brighton, MI

Jerry C.  Farmington Hills, MI

Elizabeth and Donald G.  Harrison Twp, MI

Mary Ann Z.  Fenton, MI

Sheila  K.  Oak Park, MI

Jeanene V.  Howell, MI

Paul H.  Fenton, MI

John C.  Brighton, MI

Joyce S.  Sterling Heights, MI

Steve K.  Chesterfield Twp, MI

Andrea O.  Howell, MI

David S.  Fenton, MI

Greg K.  West Bloomfield, MI

Thomas M.  Orchard Lake, MI

Virginia B.  South Lyon, MI

Carlos A.  Highland, MI

Janet H.  Hartland, MI

Rose D.  Brighton, MI

Prudence A.  Fenton, MI

Jennifer W.  Colorado Springs, CO

Peter D.  Brighton, MI

Doug S.  Fenton, MI

Kathleen F.  Macomb Township, MI

Marge M.  Howell, MI

Laura B.  Caro, MI

Sylvia C.  Brighton, MI

Thomas W.  St. Clair Shores, MI

Sue S.  Lake Orion, MI

Ray P.  Highland, MI

Joan J.  Howell, MI

Art L.  Hartland, MI

Deborah M.  Port Huron, MI

Diane D.  Birmingham, MI

Nancy H.  Fenton, MI

Barb M.  Brighton, MI

Mark W.  Clarkston, MI

Steven P.  Dexter, MI

Rose P.  Waterford, MI

Mike W.  Farmington Hills, MI

Paul W.  Fenton, MI

Margaret C.  Midland, MI

Louis F.  Gregory, MI

Marion H.  Fenton, MI

Wayne B.  Brown City, MI

Norbert Z.  Fenton, MI

Kristine E.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Mike H.  Fenton, MI

D. H.  Fenton, MI

G.R. D.  Howell, MI

Bonita C.  Eastpointe, MI

Jill M.  Highland, MI

Walter  C.  Sturgis, MI

Phil W.  Howell, MI

Loren B.  Clio, MI

Connie R.  Fenton, MI

Kim P.  Hartland, MI

Jennifer H.  Pinckney, MI

Patricia P.  Troy, MI

Diane P.  Howell, MI

Lizz J.  Brighton, MI

Milton and Jean G.  Clinton Twp, MI

David D.  Fenton, MI

Mary H.  Howell, MI

Lou Ann L.  Howell, MI

Julius S.  Fenton, MI

Jennifer H.  Saline, MI

Tomas  K.  Grandville, MI

William H.  Howell, MI

James R.  Brighton, MI

Scott B.  Grass Lake, MI

Werner W.  Shelby Twp, MI

Bill S.  Saginaw, MI

David G.  West Bloomfield, MI

Cherie M.  Fenton, MI

Tim H.  St. Clair Shores, MI

Erik N.  Warren, MI

James M.  Hartland, MI

Linda H.  Holland, MI

Debra C.  Bay City, MI

Dennis B.  Pinckney, MI

Susan M.  Highland, MI

William G.  Howell, MI

Sharon B.  Rochester Hills, MI

Matt d.  Essexville, MI

Roger K.  Fowlerville, MI

Cornelius K.  Charlotte, NC

Dennis O.  Fenton, MI

Mike I.  Commerce Twp, MI

Gordie S.  Lapeer, MI

Patrick C.  Troy, MI

Barbara F.  Brighton, MI

Scott S.  Brighton, MI

Shelia W.  Howell, MI

John H.  Hartland, MI

Robert D.  Hartland, MI

Otto G.  Ann Arbor, MI

John & Jolene C.  Howell, MI

Anna N.  Howell, MI

Susan H.  Hartland, MI

Mike S.  Durand, MI

Diane C.  White Lake, MI

Janice F.  Brighton, MI

Dennis H.  Brownstown, MI

Nancy K.  Sheridan, MI

Linda W.  Clarkston, MI

Jim & Lill M.  W. Bloomfield, MI

Jack M.  Brighton, MI

Mary K.  Garden City, MI

Betty M.  Hartland, MI

Geraldine L.  Commerce Township, MI

Joseph K.  Farmington hills, MI

Kurt P.  Hartland, MI

Alex C.  Brighton, MI

Judi B.  South Lyon, MI

Bonnie F.  Vassar, MI

Darwin H.  Perry, MI

Stewart O.  Fenton, MI

John D.  New York, NY

Mark D.  White Lake, MI

Catherine Z.  Saginaw, MI

Robert H.  Rochester, MI

Dan S.  Brighton, MI

Catherine G.  Jackson, MI

David L.  Auburn Hills, MI

Frank S.  Howell, MI

Irv K.  Brighton, MI

Bill M.  Fenton, MI

Sharon D.  Bloomfield, MI

Amy C.  Frankenmuth, MI

Jim L.  Saginaw, MI

Pam R.  Howell, MI

Anne R.  Howell, MI

Margaret M.  White Lake, MI

Dennis B.  Brighton, MI

Roger C.  Romulus, MI

Nancy E.  Portage, MI

Elaine P.  Wixom, MI

April D.  Brighton, MI

Keith N.  Sterling Heights, MI

Tom L.  Milford, MI

Dan E.  Pinckney, MI

Penelope S.  Fenton, MI

David S.  Hartland, MI

Lisa P.  Washington, MI

Orville R.  Hartland, MI

Diane W.  White Lake, MI

Margaret P.  Vassar, MI

Mariah S.  Howell, MI

Patricia O.  Fenton, MI

Jeannine S.  Boyne City, MI

Richard S.  Hartland, MI

Julie D.  Linden, MI

David K.  Fenton, MI

Louise B.  Clarkston, MI

Ralph B.  Troy, MI

Paula S.  Brighton, MI

Cheryl O.  Chelsea, MI

Elaine S.  Brighton, MI

Marlene P.  Walled Lake, MI

Liz M.  Bloomfield Hills, MI

Wes N.  Hartland, MI

William P.  Novi, MI

Robert H.   Rochester  MI

Nascar Michigan 400

RetakeOurGov Sponsors
NASCAR Vehicle

RetakeOurGov at Nascar Michigan 400

 Another milestone for RetakeOurGov as we become the first TEA Party group to sponsor a vehicle at a premiere NASCAR event. See our video and slideshow from Michigan International Speedway

Why did we form a PAC?

Many citizens have the desire to help the TEA party movement, but not the time to help.  A PAC provides these citizens with an opportunity to contribute to the movement. Read FAQ's on PAC

Leverage Your Influence

Contributing to a PAC amplifies your voice by combining your funds with the funds of other like-minded individuals.  Contributions to RetakeOurGov PAC amplify your voice by directly opposing tax and spend career politicians while simultaneously growing the strength of the TEA Party movement.  Read more

Paid for by RetakeOurGov with regulated funds, Wes Nakagiri, Treasurer, P.O. Box 37, Hartland, MI.  Not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee.  Contributions or gifts to RetakeOurGov are not tax deductible for Federal Income Tax purposes.

Would you like to make a contribution now?  Do you have a question(s) about the process?  Call us using Google Voice. Click on phone icon below and you'll be connected to our Treasurer.  (There is no charge, however, mobile phones users will incur air time usage)

Instructions: Click on icon above.  Enter your name.  Enter the phone number of your phone, that is, the one you are using to call us with. Your phone will ring shortly after clicking on "connect." Please dial "1" after answering your phone to be connected to our Treasurer.

Copyright © 2010 - 2013 RetakeOurGov.com. All rights reserved unless otherwise stated.